I feel that if you don't give anyone choices you are controlling their life. If I got told that I had to wear a winter coat in the desert, it would ruin my life.
I think this statement tells us a lot about the community. I feel that it is saying that everyone has to be the same and there shouldn't be any choices because that might be bad for them.
Look at our country though. We have risen from differences to make relationships strong. We are not still punishing England in the face for killing us in the 1800's
I think this is not true because everybody should have a choice in some things. I do not think people would be very happy or not happy at all because they do not of choices. Life would be too boring without making choices, but some people make bad choices and that will lead to another bad choice maybe. I still think that they should be able to make there own choices because that is their life, and if they want to ruin it that is their choice.
I feel that if they make bad choices it would become a problem because they will choose a something and then they might not want to do it. -Tristan Johanningmeier-
I don't think that should be true, because every one should be able to make there own choices. Even if that mean making the wrong choice. When some one makes the wrong choice they should be able to learn from that instead of never being able to learn from their own mistakes. Even if the people that made the mistake didn't learn from it they could at least get in trouble. If we all were perfect and didn't make any mistakes life would be boring.
I think this is not true because we are all our own individuals and if we all look the same, dress the same, have the same bikes, work at the same jobs, get our kids and spouses chosen for us then how do we express our personality? Wouldn't a community where everybody is excactly the same be boring? -Alyssa
I think this statement shows that if you give someone a choice they may not pick the best there is, but I think that you could pick the best choice possible but still make it not work out the way you want it to --Will
I agree with Paul, but I think that they're doing this to be perfect. Yes people should be able to make their own choices, but in a perfect world, things would go wrong. Real people like us make our own choices, but in a book it's not real so these types of things can happen.
I agree with Will. I think they should have the choice to pick for themselves as long as they have the ability to make the best choice possible. -Alyssa.
I think that everyone should have choices because if i had to wear the same thing as everyone else and look a lot alike i might just go INSANE! i like being me and i dont like how the people that their whole life dont know that they once got to make their own choices and now they dont because one little issue in the past.
i think its saying that if everybody didn't have choices then they can't make the wrong choice. If they told you what to do and how to do it then nobody would made the wrong choice because APPARENTLY they are the only ones who know whats right for you and whats wrong for you.
I feel that, if this were my community they were talking about, that that's wrong to say because everyone deserves a choice. In Jonas' community, however, if they did give people a choice, it would ruin their whole idea to keep sameness as part of their world. Giving people choice would also allow, them to have things in their community that they've never experienced before, such as color, sunshine, snow, etc.
I think thats unfair people have rights to their own choices but in the book they take them all away what if someone chose to not take the pill and fell in love and didn't want to want to have a family unit with anyone else but them? Would they let them or would they release them?
i think its dumb not being able to make your own choices because life is one BIG choice and even there they have choices just not big noticeable ones. People this second are making right choices and wrong ones but every one needs to make of bad choice everyday just so they can be human
I don't really like that statement because maybe some people would actually like to make their own choices. It would be boring on having other people decide on what you would eat,who you would marry, and what your job would be.
I agree with Hailey and Peyton, because I think that if your a human being you should be able to make whatever choice you want because that is how you learn from you mistakes but if you don't have mistakes to learn from then you really won't know anything.I also don't think anyone should tell you what you can and can't do. ~Kelsey
I think that it is wrong not to give people choice on certain things. I agree with Brieanna, if they did give them choice it would ruin sameness but on certain things they should be given a choice if wanted, like if they wanted to change the color of their shirt that should be allowed but they shouldn't be mean about it because others could do the exact same thing.
I think they don't give people choices because what if someone made the wrong choice. The choices people make won't always have to deal with them, but with the community to. So this way they don't have to worry about people making the wrong choice. Also if people were given choices they may not know the right choice since they never had choices before.
I my feelings about the giver's statement, "We don't dare give people choices," is I think he was meaning that if the people in their perfect world were to make a wrong desicion it won't be a perfect world anymore or to allow them to have the choice to having their own kids might make them disappointed if their kid were to die or get very sick or they may get jealous of the other people around them having kids and everything is fine with their kids. So in the long run it just saves the people worring or being jealos or disappointed. -Rachel-
This statement really tells us a lot about why the communitee leadership. They don't let the people have choices. That, to me, is just very wrong. People should be able to make their own choices. It is good that the people don't have to really decide anything, but it is wrong to have someone make those decisions for you. It is the people's life to live and they should not have to have someone run it for them.
I think that when he said that he meant we should let people have their own choices their choice was to have everything plain and they took away all the color and just made everything pain so you have to give people what they think and nobody knows about the real world and they want it to stay like that because the only one who knows are they givers and the receivers.. ZACH D.
I agree with Peyton, Taylor, and Landon because this statement means that nobody is to make a bad choice so no one is able to choose for themselves and more importantly some communities have more freedom than Jonas is living in.
I think that they stil have choices, just not as many as we do. But if the people got to choose everything, then they would make a vital decision that might be harmfull.
I feel that if you don't give anyone choices you are controlling their life. If I got told that I had to wear a winter coat in the desert, it would ruin my life.
ReplyDeleteI think this statement tells us a lot about the community. I feel that it is saying that everyone has to be the same and there shouldn't be any choices because that might be bad for them.
ReplyDeleteLook at our country though. We have risen from differences to make relationships strong. We are not still punishing England in the face for killing us in the 1800's
ReplyDeleteI think this is not true because everybody should have a choice in some things. I do not think people would be very happy or not happy at all because they do not of choices. Life would be too boring without making choices, but some people make bad choices and that will lead to another bad choice maybe. I still think that they should be able to make there own choices because that is their life, and if they want to ruin it that is their choice.
ReplyDelete-Hailey
I feel that if they make bad choices it would become a problem because they will choose a something and then they might not want to do it.
ReplyDelete-Tristan Johanningmeier-
I don't think that should be true, because every one should be able to make there own choices. Even if that mean making the wrong choice. When some one makes the wrong choice they should be able to learn from that instead of never being able to learn from their own mistakes. Even if the people that made the mistake didn't learn from it they could at least get in trouble. If we all were perfect and didn't make any mistakes life would be boring.
ReplyDeletei think this statement is about don't make bad choices but if you did things wouldn't turn out good so that's why he said this statement.
ReplyDelete-Theanna Martinez-
I agree with peyton, because people should be able to choose what they want to do, even if it is the wrong choice, just to make it fair.
ReplyDeletePaul
I think this is not true because we are all our own individuals and if we all look the same, dress the same, have the same bikes, work at the same jobs, get our kids and spouses chosen for us then how do we express our personality? Wouldn't a community where everybody is excactly the same be boring?
ReplyDelete-Alyssa
I think this statement shows that if you give someone a choice they may not pick the best there is, but I think that you could pick the best choice possible but still make it not work out the way you want it to --Will
ReplyDeleteI agree with Paul, but I think that they're doing this to be perfect. Yes people should be able to make their own choices, but in a perfect world, things would go wrong. Real people like us make our own choices, but in a book it's not real so these types of things can happen.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Will. I think they should have the choice to pick for themselves as long as they have the ability to make the best choice possible.
ReplyDelete-Alyssa.
If they kept up with this for many years their could be people who will figure out about the "past life". I don't think they want that.
ReplyDeleteI think that everyone should have choices because if i had to wear the same thing as everyone else and look a lot alike i might just go INSANE! i like being me and i dont like how the people that their whole life dont know that they once got to make their own choices and now they dont because one little issue in the past.
ReplyDeletei think its saying that if everybody didn't have choices then they can't make the wrong choice. If they told you what to do and how to do it then nobody would made the wrong choice because APPARENTLY they are the only ones who know whats right for you and whats wrong for you.
ReplyDeletei agree with Taylor because who would want to eat and wear the exact same thing as other people.
ReplyDeleteI feel that, if this were my community they were talking about, that that's wrong to say because everyone deserves a choice. In Jonas' community, however, if they did give people a choice, it would ruin their whole idea to keep sameness as part of their world. Giving people choice would also allow, them to have things in their community that they've never experienced before, such as color, sunshine, snow, etc.
ReplyDeleteI thinks he's being sarcastic or testing Jonas to see what his reaction will be.- Katie
ReplyDeleteI think they should give people choices, I don't want anyone running my life, I like to make my own choices.
ReplyDeleteI think thats unfair people have rights to their own choices but in the book they take them all away what if someone chose to not take the pill and fell in love and didn't want to want to have a family unit with anyone else but them? Would they let them or would they release them?
ReplyDeleteI agree with Peyton, that if we never did anything wrong, life would be boring.
ReplyDeleteTony
I agree with Brieanna, yes we should be able to make our own choices, but the idea of sameness would just fade away gradually.
ReplyDeletei think its dumb not being able to make your own choices because life is one BIG choice and even there they have choices just not big noticeable ones. People this second are making right choices and wrong ones but every one needs to make of bad choice everyday just so they can be human
ReplyDeletealex:)
I don't really like that statement because maybe some people would actually like to make their own choices. It would be boring on having other people decide on what you would eat,who you would marry, and what your job would be.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Hailey and Peyton, because I think that if your a human being you should be able to make whatever choice you want because that is how you learn from you mistakes but if you don't have mistakes to learn from then you really won't know anything.I also don't think anyone should tell you what you can and can't do.
ReplyDelete~Kelsey
I think that it is wrong not to give people choice on certain things. I agree with Brieanna, if they did give them choice it would ruin sameness but on certain things they should be given a choice if wanted, like if they wanted to change the color of their shirt that should be allowed but they shouldn't be mean about it because others could do the exact same thing.
ReplyDeleteI think they don't give people choices because what if someone made the wrong choice. The choices people make won't always have to deal with them, but with the community to. So this way they don't have to worry about people making the wrong choice. Also if people were given choices they may not know the right choice since they never had choices before.
ReplyDelete-Aubree
I my feelings about the giver's statement, "We don't dare give people choices," is I think he was meaning that if the people in their perfect world were to make a wrong desicion it won't be a perfect world anymore or to allow them to have the choice to having their own kids might make them disappointed if their kid were to die or get very sick or they may get jealous of the other people around them having kids and everything is fine with their kids. So in the long run it just saves the people worring or being jealos or disappointed.
ReplyDelete-Rachel-
This statement really tells us a lot about why the communitee leadership. They don't let the people have choices. That, to me, is just very wrong. People should be able to make their own choices. It is good that the people don't have to really decide anything, but it is wrong to have someone make those decisions for you. It is the people's life to live and they should not have to have someone run it for them.
ReplyDeleteI think that when he said that he meant we should let people have their own choices their choice was to have everything plain and they took away all the color and just made everything pain so you have to give people what they think and nobody knows about the real world and they want it to stay like that because the only one who knows are they givers and the receivers..
ReplyDeleteZACH D.
I agree with Peyton, Taylor, and Landon because this statement means that nobody is to make a bad choice so no one is able to choose for themselves and more importantly some communities have more freedom than Jonas is living in.
ReplyDeleteI think that they stil have choices, just not as many as we do. But if the people got to choose everything, then they would make a vital decision that might be harmfull.
ReplyDelete